Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Standing Up for Accountability: Protests Against Hospital Management Amid COVID-19 Crisis

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic in June and July 2020, a severe crisis unfolded in Novi Pazar, where local authorities and hospital management were ill-prepared for the epidemic. Specialist doctors from the General Hospital in Novi Pazar publicly criticized the hospital director’s mismanagement, leading 37 doctors to sign a petition calling for his removal. Despite their efforts, including a press conference, their demands went unheeded. In late June 2020, citizens protested daily, demanding accountability from the hospital’s management, particularly against then-acting director Meho Mahmutović. Many citizens took to social media to express their outrage, forming Facebook groups to discuss the hospital’s management and organizing continued demonstrations.

In response to these protests, Meho Mahmutović filed 37 private lawsuits for defamation against several activists and doctors involved in the protests. Lawyers’ Committee for Human Rights – YUCOM represented three doctors (F.P., Dž.D., and L.S.) and three activists (M.I., A.P., and A.V.), with seven lawsuits specifically targeting A.P., who had led the protests calling for accountability for the healthcare system’s poor response to the crisis.

The defendants argued that their statements were in the public interest, reflecting the shared views of many Novi Pazar citizens about the hospital’s conditions. Throughout the proceedings, the Basic and Higher courts did not fully acknowledge that the defendants’ comments represented their value judgments shared by many community members. The courts erroneously interpreted the statements as personal attacks rather than critiques of a public official’s conduct, disregarding the broader social context of the protests. Considering the first instance and appellate courts’ failure to address these legal issues adequately, the YUCOM filed two constitutional complaints to the Constitutional Court of Serbia in 2022, asserting that A.P.’s rights to a fair trial and freedom of expression were violated, as well as the specific rights of the accused.

Freedom of expression, protected uner Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, is fundamental in a democratic society. This freedom extends to all opinions, including those deemed offensive or disturbing. While such rights can be restricted, these limitations must be narrowly interpreted, with any necessary constraints robustly justified. The threshold for acceptable criticism concerns public figures more than private individuals, as public officials voluntarily subject themselves to public scrutiny and must demonstrate greater tolerance. These cases highlight the rise of SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation) claims in Serbia, where legal actions intimidate activists and suppress free speech. Despite legal provisions against abuse, courts rarely dismiss SLAPP claims.

Komitet pravnika za ljudska prava (YUCOM)
Kneza Miloša 4, 11000 Beograd, Srbija
Tel:(+ 381 11) 33-444-25; 33-44-235
office@yucom.org.rs

Copyright © YUCOM 1997 – 2024
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto, situs toto slot
bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto, Situs Toto Slot
xx1toto
bacansport
bacan4d
xx1toto, situs toto slot, bandar casino
xx1toto, situs toto slot, bandar casino
xx1toto, situs toto, toto slot
xx1toto, Situs Toto Slot
Link Situs Toto Slot
scatter hitam
xx1toto, situs toto, tabel shio
Situs Scatter Hitam Mahjong Wins 3
xx1toto
xx1toto, situs toto slot, bandar togel
situs toto slot
scatter hitam, black scatter, mahjong wins 3
mahjong scatter
situs toto
black scatter, mahjong wins 3
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacansport
bacansport
xx1toto
bacansport
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
slot gacor bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacansport
xx1toto
bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
linkbacan4d
bacan4d
bacan4d
bacansports
bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d
scatter hitam
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d slot gacor
bacan4d
xx1toto scatter hitam
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacansport
bacan4d
ts77casino bet 200
bacansport
aplikasi slot
xx1toto scatter hitam
bacan4d
bacan4d login
situs toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacansport
bacan4d
xx1toto
slottoto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d
ts77casino
ts77casino
ts77casino
ts77casino
Scatter Hitam
Situs Toto
toto slot
Scatter Hitam
Situs Toto
toto slot
bacan4d toto terpercaya
scatter hitam
slot mahjong wins 3
mahjong wins 3 black scatter
scatter hitam
ts77casino
ts77casino
tabel shio 2025
bacan4d
akun slot bet 400
bacan4d slot gacor toto
instagram bacansports
situs toto
bacan4d slot toto
scatter hitam
Situs Toto
scatter hitam
slot bet kecil
bacansports taruhan bola
slot gacor
facebook bacan4d
Demo Slot
Situs Toto
toto togel
Toto slot gacor
slot gacor bett 200
situs toto
situs toto
bacan4d scatter hitam 2025
bacan4d slot bet 300
bacansport
bacan4d situs slot toto gacor
Situs Toto Slot
Bacansports
Bacantoto Situs Toto Slot
xx1toto
xx1toto, situs toto slot
bacan4d
Situs Toto Slot, Situs Togel, toto slot, xx1toto
scatter hitam
Situs Toto Slot, Bandar Togel, Toto macau
Bacan4d Situs Toto Slot Login
xx1toto, Login Situs Toto
xx1toto, Situs Toto Slot
Situs Toto Slot, Agen Toto Slot 4D, Tabel Shio
xx1toto, situs toto, toto slot, bandar togel
xx1toto, situs black scatter hitam
Situs Toto Slot, Bandar Togel
xx1toto, situs toto
Situs Toto Slot
Situs Toto Slot
Bacantoto Situs Slot Toto Slot Gacor
xx1toto, situs toto slot
situs toto slot
Situs Idn Slot Gacor
bacansports
situs toto slot
bacansport
situs toto slot
situs slot terbaru
xx1toto, situs toto
agen toto, situs toto